(ThankYourBaby.com) – Best baby bottles for breastfeed 2018: Reviews of 10 Great Options & Top Picks. When it comes to feeding your baby we always vote for breast, but in the case you are busy with your job, you will definitely need a baby bottle. Some moms feel guilty because of that, but that isn’t wrong decision and your baby won’t suffer for that. The only important thing is to find the appropriate, quality bottle for your baby.
The market is full of different types and brands of baby bottles. The parents got confused, especially the new ones. That is why we decided to make this guide with all the features you should consider when buying a baby bottle and reviews of 10 best baby bottles for breast feeding that we tested for this purpose.
Before we start with product reviews it would be good to give you the answers to some frequently asked questions about baby bottles and to meet you with some most important features that should be considered when choosing a baby bottle.
- Main bottle parts
- Features to consider when choosing baby bottles
- 2018’s Reviews of The Best Baby Bottles for Breastfeeding
- #1 Comotomo Baby Bottle, Green
- #2 Philips Avent Classic Baby Bottles
- #3 Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Fiesta Bottle
- #4 Dr. Brown’s Original Bottle Newborn Feeding Set
- #5 Munchkin LATCH BPA-Free Newborn Baby Bottle Gift Set
- #6 Philips Avent Natural Newborn Baby Bottle Starter Set
- #7 Playtex Baby Nurser Baby Bottle with Drop-Ins Disposable Liners
- #8 Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Bottles
- #9 Munchkin Latch 4 Ounce Bottle with Bonus Nipple
- #10 Philips AVENT Anti-Colic Bottle Newborn Starter Set, Blue
- Why is the paced bottle feeding important?
- Benefits of paced bottle feeding
- How the nipple confusion can be avoided?
Is it necessary to have a bottle?
No matter if you are nursing mom, or not, it is always good to have a bottle. You will especially need a good one if you want to use a special formula to feed your baby. For the case you were nursing your little and decided to return to work in the first year of its life, but still keep to feed it with your milk, you will need a baby bottle to feed it with expressed milk.
Even if you are planning to stay home during the first year of baby’s life and nurse it, it is good to have a bottle of pumped breast milk so the other family members could help you when you are busy or have some unpredictable situation.
How to know which bottle suits your baby the most?
We recommend you to choose one brand’s starter kit and then try a few more bottles from the other brands after it and experiment with them.
You can start with smaller sized bottles designed for newborns who eat less, and then you can start with bigger bottles when you baby becomes older. The best is to get some of each, or buy one bigger bottle and put less liquid during baby’s first months of life. You can find here recommended measures according to baby’s age:
- Newborn: 1.5 to 3 ounces per meal;
- Two months old: 4 to 5 ounces per meal;
- Four months old: 4 to 6 ounces per meal;
- Six months old: 6 to 8 ounces per meal.
When is the right time for bottle?
The bottle can be used from the first day of baby’s life, but in case you are nursing your baby, it isn’t good to use bottle at least for several weeks until your little one adapts to nursing.
Recommendation of most of the lactation consultants is that you wait until milk supply is fully in and breastfeeding goes well.
This mostly happens after 2 or 3 weeks. On the other hand, for the case you are waiting too long, after 6 weeks, you can have a problem that baby refuses the bottle. Considering that fact, the most recommended time for starting with baby bottle is between 3 and 6 weeks.
For the case you introduce a bottle to your little one too early, there is a possibility that it refuses to breastfeed because milk from bottle comes out much faster.
Most of babies are fed on bottles until at least one year of their lives. The American Academy of Pediatrics suggests start giving cow’s milk then. Regardless of that, most of breastfeeding moms continue to nurse with no problems in the second year of baby’s life.
Then is also time to start adapting your baby to sippy cups that are designed to help baby’s transition from bottles to regular cups when they are between one and two years old.
What is the difference between bottle and breastfeeding?
Practice showed that this depends on baby and situation. For the case you are using bottle to feed your baby from time to time, you will come to more resistance from baby. On the other hand, some babies will adapt to first bottle you give them.
Our recommendation is to have positive attitude and believe that your little one will accept the bottle. You will make bigger problem if your baby feels your anxiety and start picking up on that and reject the bottle.
There are also some babies that prefer bottles that mimic a breast and that will help a baby to have continuity in its feeding experience.
Main bottle parts
There are 4 main bottle parts that every bottle should contain: the bottle itself, the nipple so your little one can suck, the collar that serves to screw the nipple and travel cover for the nipple.
Majority of bottle brands offer several compatible nipples designed according to different rates of milk flow. Nipples for newborns are made to provide slower milk flow in order not let them to gulp too much. On the other hand, those made for older babies with big swallows provide faster milk flow.
Features to consider when choosing baby bottles
As we mentioned at the beginning, there are lots of different baby bottles on the market so decision what to choose isn’t easy at all. Let’s see which features should be considered when buying a baby bottle.
Low flow or baby-controlled flow
While nursing, your baby is able to control the milk flow with its suck. On the other hand, when you feed it with baby bottle, it is difficult for it to control the flow because the bottle usually pours milk into baby’s mouth and doesn’t allow pause and signal that it is fed enough.
On the other hand, it also takes effort from baby to get milk from the breast, but that develops and strengthens baby’s palate and it serves as some kind of exercise. For the case you just use the bottle every day there is possibility that baby loses ability and in some cases even desire to sufficiently remove milk from the breast. If you are planning to maintain a close breastfeeding relationship this won’t be good decision.
And what about the “nipple confusion”? There are many cases where babies started to prefer the bottle because they don’t have to take effort to get the milk.
Because of this fact, the best baby bottles for breastfeeding are those with low milk flow or baby-controlled milk flow. It will be also good to choose preemie or infant nipple that can provide slow milk flow and encourage baby to retain sucking muscles.
There are three features that should be considered when looking at the nipple type.
Most of nipples are made of latex or silicone. Silicone nipples in comparison to latex are firmer and hold their shape longer, but on the other hand, latex nipples are more flexible.
Nipple size and flow
Nipples can be found in wide range of sizes and flow speeds. If you have preemie or a newborn, always choose the smallest size. This is also called “stage 1” and this type of nipples has the slowest flow.
As a child gets older, it graduates to larger sizes and faster milk flow. It also becomes able to suck more effectively and drink more breast milk or formula.
Most of the nipples are marked with the suggested age range and size. We also want to mention that you don’t have to worry about if your little one doesn’t follow these guidelines strictly. The good thing will be that you try a few different nipple sizes to see which one works the best for your kid.
Always pay attention if your baby has a hard time to get milk or it gets so much that it is spitting up and choking. We also recommend you to discuss any feeding concern with your baby’s doctor.
Nipples come in different shapes and sizes. Traditional nipples have a shape of dome or bell, while orthodontic nipples are able to accommodate baby’s gums and palate and also contain a bulb that is flat on the side and rests on baby’s tongue.
Wide and flat-topped nipples are similar to mom’s breasts and can help your baby to switch easily between breast and bottle. This type of nipples is soft and long enough to provide proper sucking. Thanks to wide textured nipple base this type resembles mom’s breasts the most.
These nipples in most of cases provide slow milk flow so you don’t have to worry when feeding your little one.
On the other hand, some babies like traditional, narrow nipple shape. Some Lactation Consultants recommend this type of nipples because the baby is able to flange its lips onto the nipple having in the same time a deep latch like it has with the breast.
The appropriate venting will provide colic and gas reduction when you little one drinks from a bottle because it can reduce the amount of air that baby swallows. These bottles contain straw-like components that fit into bottle and have a function to prevent a baby from ingesting gas-causing air bubble. The venting system can be also implemented into the nipple or bottom of the bottle.
There are 4 most used materials for baby bottles: glass, stainless steel and plastic.
Glass stands for quality and long lasting material, but in the same time heavy and these bottles are usually more expensive than other models and there is possibility to shatter it easily.
This is really strong material but disadvantage of these bottles is that you can measure precisely how much liquid is really stored in the bottle.
Polypropylene is mostly used plastic material, that can’t be easily broken and is very lightweight. A few years ago there rose certain health concerns about plastic bottles, so today all the plastic bottles are required to be free of bisphenol A (BPA).
We don’t recommend you plastic baby bottles, even if they are BPA-free because they are generally harmful. On the other hand, there is no perfect bottle but let’s say that the safest materials are silicone, glass and stainless steel.
Baby bottles made of silicone are unbreakable, BPA-free, light and soft but usually more expensive than glass and plastic. Bad thing about these bottles is that they also usually can’t be found in grocery stores or drugstores. That can cause you a problem in case the nipple breaks or cracks and you have to make a quick replacement.
There is a wide range of baby bottle shapes on the market. Traditional bottles are usually slightly curved, angled and tall. There are also wide-necked bottles that can make measuring formula easier, but on the other hand they aren’t convenient to fit into drink-holders on strollers or in cars.
It is great if you can find a bottle that has similar shape to breast. Large rounded bottles are most similar to breast shape. Considering the fact that your little one will have to work at sucking to milk having the bottle similar to breast, you will definitely help its palate formation.
Baby bottles containing drop-in plastic inserts can be convenient for the case you are on the go and in the same time they are easy to clean. All you have to do is toss the liner and wash the nipple. It is also important to mention that each insert can be used only one time.
Disposable nipples are sold sterilized and prepackaged and are handy to pop on a bottle.
Number and size
The number of baby bottles that you will need change during your baby’s life varies from 4 to 12. That depends on your decision whether you will use breastfeeding or bottle-feeding.
It is recommended to start with 4-ounce baby bottles. These bottles are good for small amounts of breast milk or formula. Then when your little one reaches 4 months you can start using 8- or 9-ounce bottles.
Know when you’ve got the answers to frequently asked questions and met with the most important features that should be considered when buying a baby bottle, let’s see what the best baby bottles for breastfeeding are.
2018’s Reviews of The Best Baby Bottles for Breastfeeding
This is 100% hygienic medical grade silicone baby bottle shaped like a breast. Thanks to its flexibility, this bottle mimics a breast and encourages a baby to be active in “letting down” the milk, the same as in breastfeeding. Because of the slow flow silicone nipple this can be a good choice for breastfed babies.
There is a better grip for smaller hands thanks to skin-like silicone material. It also provides to a baby a feeling similar to holding its mom’s breast.
The bottle contains a super wide mouth for easy cleaning by hand without using a brush. Another good thing is that the bottle is completely safe in boiling water, dishwasher, microwave and sterilizer.
We want you to keep in mind that silicone is safest when it isn’t heated, so in case you want to heat the milk we recommend you to use another container.
Common problem with baby bottles is leaking because it gets messy and a baby isn’t fed enough. This model has little leaking because of the wider nipple design while baby feeds around nipple, but on the other hand, this is natural result during the breastfeeding as well.
This silicone bottle can be manipulated by baby or parent in order to squeeze milk out for a similar effect to letting down milk in mom and all that thanks to dual anti-colic vent valves that don’t interfere with feeding.
Philips baby bottle contains clinically proven, anti-colic system integrated into the nipple so the bottle is very easy to clean and assemble. While feeding your little one the unique valve on the nipple opens in order to allow air into the bottle instead of baby’s tummy.
When choosing a baby bottle you shouldn’t forget that sleep and nutrition are very important to baby’s health. This bottle reduces fussing in great measure by approximately 28 minutes a day in comparison to the comparator bottle. This is especially noticeable during the night.
This model allows a baby to control milk flow and reduce spit-up, gas and burping. It is possible thanks to the unique valve on the nipple.
The bottle is designed to prevent leaking during the feeding with leak preventing ring, but in practice it leaks a little.
Thanks to only 4 parts, rounded corners and wide bottle neck this baby bottle is very easy to be cleaned.
Unique shape allows easy holding and gripping in any direction and provides maximum comfort even if the baby has tiny hands.
There are different nipple flow rates available with this model that will follow baby’s growth. They are available in twin packs: Newborn, Slow, Medium, Fast and Variable.
The most important thing when it comes to baby products is safety and this baby bottle is BPA free.
As its name says, this bottle is designed to provide feeding as natural as possible.
This is possible thanks to special nipple used for this bottle model. The nipple is made of soft to touch, silicon-based material that resembles human skin. The shape and nipple stretchiness are also similar to mom’s breast and facilitate easier latching on.
The nipple also contains super sensitive valve that makes feeding more effective and provides better consumption of the bottle’s content.
This bottle is designed to facilitate three ways of holding it. It can be hold firmly, in traditional way you can cradle the bottle or hold it on the base. The bottle is also pretty compact and enables you to come closer to a baby so it can feel your presence more acutely.
Even if it is made of plastics, the bottle is BPA free.
The bottle can be easily cleaned and maintained. It is also dishwasher safe. The construction is sturdy so you don’t have to worry about the damage during the extensive usage.
Dr. Brown’s is a producer of the original anti-colic, anti-fuss, anti-gas bottles since 1996. This manufacturer uses a unique vent system made by Dr. Brown. He was a pediatrician whose most famous work was a design and patent for two-piece venting system that has a purpose to prevent the negative pressure “vacuum” that often appears in bottles during the feeding.
The same as with natural breasts, this baby bottle creates a positive-pressure flow. This model can be a good solution for mothers who switch between breast- and bottle-feeding but also for those who only bottle feed.
The first version of this bottle being made two decades was evaluated to BPA-free plastic. This reduced the cost, lightness in weight but nothing can replace the glass bottle.
Disadvantage of this model is that vent system can be little hard to clean.
This Munchkin’s product is one of the newest in the market bringing some innovative features. It has unique anti-colic valve located on the bottom of the bottle with the purpose to reduce the complexity of the washing process.
This design is inspired by latch process and nipple is created to mimic the movement, feel and let-down of a mom’s breast. The nipple has the ability to stretch while the baby sucks in order to allow the nipple to maintain a good latch.
During the feeding, as baby consumes more milk the air is allowed by the valve to enter the bottle and it increases in that way the negative pressure and reduces air ingestion. If there is a less air ingested, there will be less burping and colic.
The bad side is that we noticed during the testing we made that nipple became pushed in a few times and that was pretty frustrating. This design also makes this bottle difficult to clean.
This model is pretty similar to Tommee Tippee when it comes to functionality, but in comparison to Tommee, this bottle has narrower overall screw base and narrower nipple base as well. The nipples are soft and compliant and fast lath-on.
Thanks to twin valve venting system air swallowing, colic and gas are prevented. In comparison to other twin valves on our list, these are completely different. Thanks to reasonably wide nipple base baby will have the feel of real breast.
The bottle is also easy to clean thanks to wide neck. In comparison to this model Comotomo and Tommee Tippee from our list are much easier to clean.
It comes in glass and plastic version and both are BPA-free and free of harmful chemicals. The same as Comotomo and Tommee Tippee this bottle has a nice ergonomic shape.
During the last few years this manufacturer used thinner plastic but the functionality hasn’t been changed.
This product is recognizable by its tough design that makes it reliable and you won’t have to worry about whether it will some malfunctions next time or not.
What we don’t like is that this model is made of plastics, but it is BPA-free. The manufacturer managed to completely exclude BPA elements from this model.
A good side of this model construction is that it prevents the air to enter from the outside and mix up with the milk. This also guarantees that baby drink is completely authentic and has been compromised by no outside imperfections. Thanks to its softness it resembles to breast and that makes the baby more comfortable during the feeding.
One of the greatest dangers when it comes to breast feeding is that gasses and colic can be mixed up with the milk and enter the baby’s stomach. With this model gasses and colic particles are brought to minimum thanks to tightly-sealed top along with the collapsible body that protects the milk from any outside imperfections or possible unhealthy particles.
It is also important to mention that each bottle is pre-sterilized in a Playtex’s factory.
The bottle also has a nice shape that is easy to handle.
This model is very similar to Comotomo, especially when it comes to nipple, shape and venting. It has a wide body with nice curvature for grip. In comparison to Comotomo the nipple isn’t so wide but the construction is almost the same.
Our test showed that the nipple replicates a natural elongation and retraction movement, but Comotomo’s nipple is slightly better. The nipple is very similar to human skin. The bottle is made in a way that can be held firmly in hand in several ways.
Thanks to wider and shorter stance this bottle is easy to clean. The venting is similar to Comotomo, but in comparison to it, it has a single vent. Single vent works fine, but during the testing we noticed that it is covered by chin, lips and cheek and that doesn’t make venting so good and with twine vent.
The material is BPA-free.
This can be a good solution for moms that want to switch between breast- and bottle-feeding.
This baby bottle can be a good solution for breastfed infants, infants with colic. The bottle is designed to make your little one work to express the milk and prevent drips as well. It will make your baby suck harder and build up stronger muscles which is close to breastfeeding technique.
The nipple has accordion style and is able to tilt at different angles that makes bottle feeding easier. It also can be stretched in order to reach the back of the soft palate in order to ensure that baby maintains a proper latch. Thanks to this feature, a baby will be able to keep the nipple in its mouth while it moves its head.
This nipple design that mimics breastfeeding enables your little one to control how much milk is released.
The bottle also contains anti-colic valve at the bottom that prevents air bubbles from floating to the nipple and in the same time allows the milk to flow freely.
Disadvantage of this model is that sometimes when baby starts drinking the nipple can suction in shortly after and you will have to pop it back out. The tilt also doesn’t bend enough.
This BPA-free contains a clinically proven anti-colic valve for less air in baby’s tummy and provides more comfortable feeding experience. This model is designed to grow with your baby. It contains a set of two anti-colic bottle 9 ounce/260ml bottles with slow flow nipples, and two anti-colic 4 ounce/125ml bottles with newborn nipples.
What also included in this set are Bottle Brush, My First Transition Cup, Formula Dispenser and one Newborn Pacifier.
Orthodontic, translucent pacifier included in this set has the function to keep baby calm between feedings. It is made of taste and odor-free silicone. There is also collapsible nipple designed according to natural development of baby’s palate, gums and teeth.
Trainer cup is included in set with the purpose to help a baby to graduate from bottles to common cups.
Why is the paced bottle feeding important?
For the case you have a plan to go back to work during the first year of baby’s life, we believe you will start storing and pumping milk. When you find the appropriate bottle for your little one, it is left to know how to feed your baby with bottle in a right way. All you need is to know how the paced bottle feeding works.
Paced bottle feeding is a way of feeding a baby that simulates breastfeeding. As its name says, this method includes pacing your feedings in order to allow your little one to be in “control” of process and recognize its feeling of fullness. In this way your baby will eat slowly and in the same time work harder to get the milk which is opposite to standard bottle feeding.
Choosing baby bottle isn’t easy decision having so many different brands and types on the market. That is why is always good to consider the features like: milk flow, nipple type, venting system, material and bottle shape before making the final decision.
Considering these features, the winner from our list of the 10 best baby bottles for breastfeeding is Comotomo baby bottle. It has a silicone body and nipple that resemble the bottle to mom’s breast. This will help your little one to transit easily from breast to bottle. It is completely safe and healthy and your baby can keep it with its little arms.
The disadvantages of this baby bottle are minor in comparison to benefits this bottle brings.
This is just our opinion based on the test we made. We always recommend you try a few bottles and see which one suits your baby the best.s